News Ticker:

Home

Do You Think Illegal Aliens Help or Hurt our Economy?

East Texans respond to newly released numbers on the Economic Impact of Ilegal Aliens.

October 6, 2009 - 6:32am

Tyler—

Do you think people in this country illegally, help our economy, or are they so much a burden to healthcare and other government services, the illegal population is harmful to the economy?


36 comments

According to the Texas State Comptroller, if all illegal aliens were to vanish from the state, our net loss in one year would be....17.3 billion dollars. Just as we changed our ways when we moved from the slide rule to the electronic calculator, so also has our economy shifted to accommodate this work force. And just as we will never revert to slide rules instead of calculators, neither will we go back to the way things were done prior to the illegal alien workforce. And you can bet your boots the majority of Americans will not take the jobs these folks are holding.

William W. Lamar

1 week ago

In every country you have to have citizenship, and the U.S.A. should not be an exception to the rule. You can't run a country in hopes to prosper, based on anyone can show up and be illegal, meanwhile the people that are citzens here have to pay their tax dollars to the IRS, and for their healthcare, while others that aren't citzens get it free, including childbirth. If illegals are complaining they should not, because they don't belong here, and it won't be long that this country will not be able to support families for free. It's not fair to the people that do belong here. I dont believe that all people should have to have a college education in America just to beat out all the other illegals for jobs. That's ridiculous! My grandfather had no college education. He was self employed with a bulldozer business and a farming business, and for that you don't need an education, but he should not have to wrongfully be paying for others to be here not paying their taxes, not paying for their heathcare, and most of all not even being in their country! It's jobs like those that my grandfather had, that are being taken by people who are illegal. We are now at the worst job loss in the country since the 1930's. U.S. citizens are giving up on finding work now. There are too many people in the U.S. right now that should not be, to include dangerous terrorists filtering in. Our country is being ruined by people that don't belong here, and so is it being overpopulated as well. We can't just keep letting whoever come here. Even if everyone had their citizenship, at some point you have to stop letting everyone over here, because the country will be an undesirable place to live one day. I don't care what anyone has to say...we aren't responsible and shouldn't have to pay the price for another country's people.

RETROQUEEN

3 weeks ago

if an illagel alien took ur job, u must of had a crapy job, becuse they get paid like crapy. whats hurting this country is the goverment paying people that stays home and get paid with people tax money and yall blame this on mexicans!!! illagel aliens cant get that...!!!!!! and YES they help the economy

mexican

2 months ago

Illegal aliens do hurt the ecomony they get jobs and work for nothing just so they can try to stay if you ask me and you did I think everyone should go back to where they come from. This land we call AMERICA is not what it used to be and the meaning of AMERICA is gone. This used to be a black and white country now it is all cultures of the world legal and illegal so if the people make AMERICA a place for everyone and they butt in everybodies business that make illegal people want to be here and make AMERICA a place that can not take care of thier own people.

Kay Lewis

1 month ago

First of all, Indians were here first if you all remembered History. Some people are just lazy, some people take advantage of the mexicans doing all the work in the heat (I've seen it myself), we cut the crops, and we work our butts off. Some people (not just mexicans) depends on the governement to take care of them. Back then the blacks were slaves, it feels now the mexicans are slaves doing all the work. So they are helping us.

mary arroyo

3 weeks ago

YES!! Illegal aliens definitely crap all over our East Texas towns.
Send them all back. Round them up like cattle and deport them "en-masse"

They do not care where they are! Only make money. Send them back and let their own country deal with the problem. All they do here is leave crap everywhere!

mrchuck

2 months ago

WOULD YOU IDIOTS DO ME A FAVOR AND FORGET THE ALAMO!! The Alamo is a tourist attraction in the middle of downtown San Antonio. It does not stand for anything.

The illegal immigration is a two part problem. Let me break it down for you.

You may not know this but the illegals are here because American/Texas companies keep hiring them!!!! It is like the movie Field of Dreams "if you build it they will come" -if you all keep hiring them - guess what? THEY WILL COME!!

Instead of posting comments about the doomed future of America - just pick up the phone and call 1-866-DHS-2-ICE IT IS A TOLL FREE CALL PEOPLE. These people are in plain sight. Just walk into any fast food restaurant with golden arches in the Tyler area. As you place your order - look back into the kitchen area - you will see what I mean.

And if you feel displaced from your job because of illegal aliens - then you should have studied more in school and made something more of yourself so that you would have a competitive edge. If you already speak English then go to community college and learn something to better yourself. But if you want to hang around your trailer park all day and blame the illegals for your current social standing -you can do that also if it makes you feel better about yourself.

The solution is SOOOOO SIMPLE - STOP GIVING THEM WORK - without work they won't stick around - they won't buy houses or cars or shop at WalMart - and their kids won't go to your schools - they won't use the emergency room as their primary care doctor - they won't request any Federal assistance for their U.S. born children.

Once the illegals are gone then jobs will be plentiful and American people will have their pick of employment and salaries will be great and the benefits will just flow.

Would it not be MAJORLY WONDERFUL when great red blooded American people will have the incredibly great opportunity again to; flip burgers, cut lawns, trim trees, work at dry cleaners, clean houses, harvest fruits and vegetable, work at hotels as houskeepers, work as construction laborers, work the rose nursery, work at the plant farms, country club golf courses and chicken processing plants. Just imagine that great day - almost reminds me of the song "It's a Wonderful World" by Louie Armstrong.

Your chest would burst with pride as you drive by a Highway Construction site like the Loop 49 project and see nothing but natural born Americans toiling in the burning August sun. I don't know about you but - I would roll down my window and salute them.

This is possible people - if you just QUIT COMPLAINING and start calling 1-866-DHS-2-ICE. REMEMBER to also report the employer who is "aiding and abetting" criminal conduct by ILLEGALLY hiring illegal aliens. Again the number is 1-866-DHS-2-ICE and if you call in the next 15 minutes we will double the arrest for the price of one - tell them Billy Mays sent you.

Truthfinder

2 months ago

if america didnt really want us here they could keep us out, keep on payin and giving us food stamps is a way of telln us we are welcome so for all ya that yell go home illegals need to be mad at the government not at the mexican

wetback

2 months ago

We pay in so if we needed Benefits it would be there for american citizens. So if you want OUR BENEFITS you need to work and pay taxes like the rest of us and not use us. You push yourselves on us and use our tax dollars to pay for your babies and use food stamps and any other program out there to support yourselves while you send money home. That doesn't benefit our economy it hurts it more than anything. Because you spend up our money and you send it back to where your from. While taking jobs that the Citizens could work. If you respected yourselves and your children and us you would become a citizen and do things right.

Go Home

1 month ago

AMEN!

RETROQUEEN

3 weeks ago

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
This field is for SPAM prevention and should be left blank. If you see this please ignore it.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
9
G
F
P
F
W
Enter the code without spaces and pay attention to upper/lower case.