Mental Illness: What makes someone become a shooter?

POSTED: Tuesday, August 14, 2012 - 10:00pm
UPDATED: Saturday, August 18, 2012 - 6:45pm
Tyler, Texas — In the past two months there have been three tragic and unexpected shootings.
After each shooting, there have been reports stating that the shooters had something in common.
We took a look at the last three shooters that have caused tragedy and horror for friends and family across the nation and found that reports state that they had some sort of a mental illness.
Twenty-four year old James Holmes killed twelve people in Aurora, Colorado and reports state that his mother said that she wasn't surprised to find out her son had done this.
The Huffington Post also stated that Holmes psychiatrist said he may be a threat to colleagues.
We also asked the owner of Shootist Gun & Knife Shop in Tyler if there are warning signs of people who shouldn't be buying a gun.
Mack Woods told KETK, "I think everybody has a sixth sense about people that might be up to doing them harm, or have issues that we don't want to harm those issues even more than they might be set up, I watch for body language, I watch for comments they might throw out there showing that they might do something crazy."
Licensed councilor, David Wheeler, from ETMC's Behavioral Health Clinic told KETK that family members should stay close to loved one's who show signs of insanity or depression, so that these type of situations don't happen.
Forty year old Wade Michael Page killed six people and died while shooting up a temple in Wisconsin. After the shooting a former soldier with Page told The Milwaukee Journal that he regrets covering up Page's suicide attempt in the past.
However, Wheeler told KETK that he believed Page had a problem with alcohol and he may have said he was going to kill himself while inebriated and it would have been difficult to know if he was serious or not. He believed that Page's violent acts were a hate crime.
Thirty-five year old Thomas Caffall killed two people and died during a shooting near Texas A & M. His mother told "Click2Houston" he had mental difficulties, was very troubled and his step father called him a ticking time bomb.
Woods told KETK, "There are some people who have spent a great deal of time locked up in mental facilities who ingest a great deal of mental health medication usually called head meds everyday which alters the perception with which they see things."
Wheeler said that Caffall was out of the job for a while and must have very depressed and just lost it when he was getting evicted. He also said that if he had not been out of the job and lost all self esteem he may never had done something like this.
So what is it that makes people cross the line and react in such violent ways?
Woods told KETK that he believes there is a difference between a mental illness that is treated with medication and under control, and someone who is mentally disturbed, and those people should never be allowed to buy firearms.
Comments News Comments
rest of my post is
Some of us and our family members living with psychotic illnesses don't believe that they should be Some of us and our family members don't believe they should be allowed to deteriorate in an untreated psychosis in case of future relapses.
I discuss these issues in a recent article:
http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/susan-inman/mental-illness-and-violence_b_1...
Susan Inman
This article makes some very good points. However, it doesn't include some key pieces of information.
We need to acknowledge that people with untreated psychosis do have a higher rate of violence than do the general population. Also, it's crucial to recognize that most people experiencing psychosis have a well-document and neurobiologically based inability to understand that they are ill. Some of us and our family members living with psychotic illnesses don't believe that they should be allowed
I'm unimpressed. I though the author might have made an effort to actually give the public some kind of answer to the intriguing question the title poses. But there is not one observation made that gives an insight into what makes someone a shooter. Perhaps the question is unanswerable or too complex to state in a short article. The conclusion rushed and feels a little forced. There's a difference between a mentally ill person who takes meds and one that doesn't? and that makes you a shooter?
There are conflicting statements in this article about medications - one that they alter perceptions and one that they help keep mental illness under control. 50% of people in the United States will have a diagnosable serious mental illness at some point in their lifetime. So, look around, and you will see that about half of the people that you are around could go off any second because they are "insane" or "mentally disturbed." (whatever those terms mean). Check your facts KETK.
This news story is poorly researched. The truth is that mental health professionals observe the same signs and symptoms on a daily or weekly basis that were demonstrated by these shooters. It is a case of confirmation bias. In other words, we can look back and find that in a given population that possibly 1000's of people have the same presentation - get evicted, lost their job, had mental difficulties, etc. The best instruments that we have for violence prediction are not accurate at all.












