Once again, Senate rejects House GOP plan to derail Obamacare

Once again, Senate rejects House GOP plan to derail Obamacare
Senate TV/CNN

POSTED: Monday, September 30, 2013 - 4:24pm

UPDATED: Monday, September 30, 2013 - 9:05pm

CNN UPDATE (5:14 p.m. ET): A government shutdown due to political wrangling over federal spending and Obamacare would throw a wrench into the gears of the economy, President Barack Obama said Monday. In comments at the White House, Obama said a shutdown beginning at midnight would represent the "height of irresponsibility" and "does not have to happen."

ORIGINAL STORY (CNN): With a government shutdown looming, politicians in Washington were talking at each other Monday instead of negotiating a way to avoid it.

In the latest volley of legislative ping pong over a short-term spending plan needed to avoid a shutdown at midnight, Senate Democrats again rejected a House proposal that also would derail Obamacare.

The 54-46 Senate vote on strict party lines returned the focus to the Republican-led House, where Speaker John Boehner said another effort would be made to attach provisions that would delay President Barack Obama's signature health care reforms from full implementation starting Tuesday.

Despite repeated rejection by the Democratic-led Senate and a veto threat by Obama, House Republicans will raise the stakes by also forcing a vote on a provision to eliminate government health care subsidies for the president and members of Congress and their staff, Boehner said.

Nicknamed the nuclear option, the proposal would require Democrats to essentially vote in favor of giving themselves and their staff members government subsidies for health coverage by protecting Obamacare from the latest Republican attack.

The Obamacare subsidies are similar to the health care coverage that private employers provide their workers.

GOP Rep. James Lankford of Oklahoma told CNN that the Affordable Care Act was written to ensure that politicians including the president would receive the same health care options and costs as people who purchase private health coverage within the system.

"I think it's right to have employer provided health care, but the way the law is written, it's not allowed," Lankford said.

Without congressional approval of spending legislation, parts of the federal government will begin shutting down when the current fiscal year ends at midnight, forcing agencies to furlough thousands of workers and curtail some services until there is a resolution.

"I feel sad about it. We expect more from our Congress," said Vick Temple, who works for the Federal Aviation Administration.

The public more broadly also doesn't like the idea of a shutdown and neither does Wall Street as nervous investors sent stocks lower.

But members of Congress persisted in blaming the other side as the shutdown deadline neared.

Republican Rep. Renee Ellmers of North Carolina said on CNN's "New Day" that her party continues to be deeply concerned about Tuesday's scheduled opening of Obamacare health insurance exchanges and "keeping the checkbook out of Barack Obama's hands and the damage can be done there."

Rep. Debbie Wasserman Shultz, D-Florida, appearing alongside Ellmers, characterized the Republican strategy of tying overall government operations to at least a delay in health care changes as "irrational."

"It jeopardizes the economy and it makes no sense," she said.

Obama told reporters he wasn't resigned to a shutdown, but he signaled its likelihood even as he indicated possible talks with congressional leaders.

"I suspect that I will be speaking to the leaders today, tomorrow and the next day," Obama said at a joint appearance with visiting Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who acknowledged the Washington brouhaha by thanking the president for meeting with him "on what I know is a very busy day for you."

The latest plan rejected by Senate Democrats would have delayed Obamacare for a year and repealed a tax on medical devices.

Last week, the Senate voted down a House GOP plan to eliminate funding for Obamacare in a short-term spending plan to keep the government running in the new fiscal year that begins Tuesday.

Democrats has pressured Boehner to give up a losing fight over Obamacare forced by tea party conservatives and instead hold a vote on a "clean" spending plan that includes no provisions seeking to undermine the health care reforms.

On CNN, Wasserman Schultz predicted that such a measure would pass easily with support from all Democrats and more moderate Republicans.

Some Republicans expressed frustration Monday with the tactics of their congressional colleagues. Veteran GOP Sen. John McCain of Arizona noted that any attempt to repeal Obamacare would fail because of Obama's veto, which would require a two-thirds majority in the Senate to overcome.

"There's not 67 votes in the United States Senate, therefore, ergo, we're not going to repeal Obamacare," McCain said. "Okay? That's it. We may do this for a day. We may do it for a week. We may do it for a month. It's going to end up the same way. "

GOP Rep. Charlie Dent of Pennsylvania told CNN Chief Congressional Correspondent Dana Bash that whichever party was to blame, a shutdown will make everyone look bad.

"At this point, the hourglass is nearly empty," Dent said. "Now that we've sent over two volleys to the U.S. Senate and they rejected both."

Trying again would only yield the same result, he continued, adding that "sooner or later, we have to pass a clean resolution to fund the government before the end of the day."

"I believe the votes are there to do it," Dent said.

Obama and Democrats reject what they call Republican efforts to use the threat of a government shutdown to force negotiations on the president's signature health care reforms.

Noting that the 2010 Affordable Care Act has been upheld by the Supreme Court, they say it is settled law that voters endorsed last year by re-electing Obama over GOP candidate Mitt Romney, who campaigned on repealing it.

Obama said Monday that a simple solution to avoid a government shutdown was to "set aside the short-term politics" and instead focus on a long-term budget deal.

"It simply requires everybody to act responsibly and do what's right for the American people," he said.

A new CNN/ORC poll shows that Americans are not happy about the prospect of a shutdown, which is happening because Congress has been unable to pass a budget for the new fiscal year that begins Tuesday.

According to the poll, 68% of Americans think shutting down the government for even a few days is a bad idea, while 27% think it's a good idea.

And it appears most Americans would blame congressional Republicans for a shutdown: Sixty-nine percent said they agreed with the statement that the party's elected officials were acting like "spoiled children."

Democrats, however, weren't far behind: Fifty-eight percent of respondents said they too were acting like spoiled kids.

Stock traders also seemed solidly against a shutdown. The Dow Jones Industrial Average fell by more than 120 points, or nearly 1 percent, and the other two major indexes also closed lower.

Among major economic issues that could result from a shutdown: delays in processing FHA housing loan applications -- a potential drag on the housing recovery -- and the potential loss of government spending that's helping prop up the economy, said Christine Romans, host of CNN's "Your Money."

"You've got an economy right now that's very tied to government spending and government contracts, so that could have a ripple effect all across Main Street," she said on CNN's "New Day."

If the government does shut down, it would be the first time it has happened in more than 17 years. That previous shutdown, sparked by a budget battle between Democratic President Bill Clinton and a Republican Congress, lasted for 21 days.

While the military will remain on duty, as will many essential public safety, health and welfare operations, many government offices will close. About a quarter of the federal government's 3.3 million employees -- those frequently referred to as "nonessential" -- will be told to stay home from work until the shutdown is over.

Attorney General Eric Holder and Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel said essential crime prevention and military services would continue, but some workers would be furloughed. Holder said he would cut his pay by the same amount as the most severely affected Justice Department employees because "we are all in this together."


CNN's Michael Pearson, Holly Yan, Ted Barrett, Lisa Desjardins and Deirdre Walsh contributed to this report.

™ & © 2013 Cable News Network, Inc., a Time Warner Company. All rights reserved.

Comments News Comments

And once again we see why the Democrats need to be voted out.

2014 is almost here, time for a TEA PARTY to oust the Democrats in the Senate.

Post new Comment